Written by: Brandon Thomas
Art by: Fico Ossio
Colors by: Ulises Arreola
Letters by: Lucas Gattoni
Cover art by: Fico Ossio, Ulises Arreola
Cover price: $3.99
Release date: December 11, 2024
Black Lightning #2, by DC Comics on 12/11/24, follows Anissa as she struggles with her uncontrolled power and complicated feelings toward her father as the Absolute Power fallout spirals.
Is Black Lightning #2 Good?
First Impressions
Clunky, disjointed, annoying, and unsatisfying. These are just a few words that come to mind after reading writer Brandon Thomas's entry in Jefferson Pierce's life story. It's a shame because Black Lightning #2 has all the pieces for a thoughtful examination of the consequences of Amanda Waller's failed attempt to take over the world, but the issue is mired in poor character work, ugly scene transitions, and a cloudy plot.
Recap
When last we left Jefferson Pierce in Black Lightning #1, the electricity-based superhero struggled to settle into his new role as seeker and counselor of citizens imbued with power from the fallout of Absolute Power. Black Lightning and his daughter tracked an anomaly spiraling out of control on a city subway, but our hero was shocked to learn the anomaly was his second daughter, Anissa.
Plot Synopsis
In Black Lightning #2, we catch up sometime after the big reveal that Anissa is one of the recipients of new power after the Task Force VII Amazos were defeated. Anissa vents her frustrations about her father to a robotic counselor aboard the new Watchtower. Meanwhile, Black Lightning and Lightning tackle one meta outbreak after another in and around Metropolis.
Anissa eventually storms out of the counseling session when questions about her negative feelings toward her father grow increasingly uncomfortable. Black Lightning and Lightning meet her in the Watchtower when Anissa demands to be taken home, but Jefferson is called to a Watchtower-wide emergency, so he asks Lightning to take Anissa home. Instead of going straight home, Lightning takes her sister to see their mother at Steelworks.
Elsewhere, Isaac, the student who received powers in issue #1, is at home watching the news. The angry, anti-meta rhetoric from Councilman Harriman scares Isaac, but his mother steps in to turn off the television and encourage him to relax while she goes to work. Isaac uses his alone time to visit Steelworks, hoping to connect with Lightning.
The issue ends with Volcana and two unnamed allies attacking Steelworks for some reason, prompting Lightning and Natasha to suit up for battle.
What’s great about Black Lightning #2?
If you read the 1st Impressions section above, you already know the value of this issue is the potential of the pieces. Brandon Thomas has the opportunity to lead one of the few titles that show how the fallout of Absolute Power is affecting everyday people across the globe. On that point, Thomas succeeds in showing a world fighting a huge mess that strains the Justice League and, by extension, the people in their lives.
Yes, a big event should show consequences. If DC isn't going to reboot the universe, impactful consequences are the next best thing.
What’s not great about Black Lightning #2?
Oof! Brandon Thomas has all the pieces, but he puts them together like a post-modernist interpretation of a knotted ball of yarn. Scenes begin out of nowhere, or you're dropped into the middle of scenes without context, and the issue begins days after the last issue's cliffhanger for no real reason. There's no cohesion, no flow, and no real point to this issue other than to highlight Anissa has a really bad attitude toward her father.
On that last point, Thomas goes over the top by presenting Anissa as an unreasonable, emotionally immature brat, which is a stark contrast to any recent appearance of Anissa. If Thomas's goal was to make Anissa look as obnoxiously self-involved and unfair as possible, he succeeded. Considering the egregious character assassination of Andy Curry by Thomas in his Future State run, I'm starting to suspect Thomas has a problem presenting certain types of characters. We'll leave it at that.
How’s the Art?
Fico Ossio's artwork is pretty darn good and probably deserves more praise for making Thomas's awkward script look presentable. The few wow moments available hit hard, and the overall look of the issue is energetic.
About The Reviewer: Gabriel Hernandez is the Publisher & EIC of ComicalOpinions.com, a comics review site dedicated to indie, small, and mid-sized publishers.
Follow @ComicalOpinions on YouTube, Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter
Final Thoughts
Black Lightning #2 has all the makings of a great story as one of the few DC titles showing the consequences of Absolute Power. Unfortunately, Brandon Thomas's directionless plot and disjointed execution waste the opportunity.
5/10
We hope you found this article interesting. Come back for more reviews, previews, and opinions on comics, and don’t forget to follow us on social media:
Connect With Us Here: Weird Science DC Comics / Weird Science Marvel Comics
If you're interested in this creator’s works, remember to let your Local Comic Shop know to find more of their work for you. They would appreciate the call, and so would we.
Click here to find your Local Comic Shop: www.ComicShopLocator.com
As an Amazon Associate, we earn revenue from qualifying purchases to help fund this site. Links to Blu-Rays, DVDs, Books, Movies, and more contained in this article are affiliate links. Please consider purchasing if you find something interesting, and thank you for your support.
I would say he has a problem with giving characters as fair a treatment as he could give period. Despite the plot being interesting enough both here and during his outsiders' run, there is a tendency to keep berating a certain character with no reason from start to finish even when clearly they don't have any fault there and giving all the benefit to another. Here the character for that choice is Black lightning. He can't do anything without it being commented on negatively by Anissa and for outsiders it was Batman. (Though here at least some characters do defend BL against unfair treatment and the narrative seems somewhat aware. With Batman literally he was the most understanding person in that room and then he would get a long lecture by Shiva among other people on parenthood!!! As if she as a abuser who let her daughter be tortured into a killing machine has any right to talk back to anyone on the subject of parenthood and mentorship. Before anyone says yeah but that is how Shiva thinks, not what actually is, I will say this: there is a clear difference between characters believing something, and the narrative agreeing with them. You could get the meaning by the framing, events, art etc. It's hard to explain but as a reader people usually get the difference instinctively. And Thomas usually writes these scenarios in a way that feels like he agrees with or at least finds it not obnoxious)
ReplyDeleteHis writing quality has been overrated imo in general. However I do commend the commitment to show the fallout of events in the world cause a very small percentage of writers bother with that where it should be a rule.